Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
master with private entrance & deck
master walk in
master deck
main deck
queen and twin upstairs
queen downstairs
queen and twin upstairs
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach - Fair Harbor, New York
tub too
shower stall
Everyones Fav is the outdoor shower
19/19
  All Photos

Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach

2-6 Keys4 Bedrooms10 Guests2 BathsView Amenities

Description

Coastal Comfort Just Steps from the Beach

Set in the heart of Fair Harbor—known as the jewel of Fire Island—this elegant beachside retreat offers a refined yet relaxed island experience. Surrounded by salty breezes and sun-warmed pathways, the home blends classic coastal charm with modern updates, including fresh renovations and thoughtful enhancements planned for the upcoming season. With an open-concept layout and generous indoor-outdoor flow, the residence invites guests to unwind, connect, and take in the natural rhythm of seaside living.

The home is designed with comfort and simplicity in mind. Upstairs, two serene bedrooms each feature a queen and twin bed configuration, accompanied by a newly remodeled full bathroom. On the main level, two additional bedrooms and a second bathroom offer flexible accommodations for larger groups. The open-plan living space provides ample room for gathering, dining, and unwinding after a day in the sun. Subtle beach-inspired décor, airy interiors, and casual elegance define the atmosphere, creating a peaceful backdrop for every season.

Just three minutes from the shoreline, the location allows for easy beach access and leisurely walks along the sand. Residents can enjoy the ease of a car-free community, where bikes are the preferred mode of travel and scenic water taxis offer effortless exploration of neighboring towns. The home includes beach chairs, umbrellas, and new bikes, making seaside adventures simple and spontaneous. In the evenings, join locals at the dock for Fair Harbor’s beloved sunset tradition—a legal cocktail hour complete with live music, homemade treats from neighborhood kids, and a warm, welcoming spirit.

Beyond the shoreline, the area offers a range of experiences to complement your island stay. Explore Sailors Haven and the Sunken Forest, a rare maritime holly forest just a short bike ride away. Visit Kismet or Ocean Beach for dining and boutique shopping, or take in the vibrant arts and crafts scene unique to Fire Island. Whether you’re paddleboarding along the bay, sampling fresh seafood, or simply stargazing from the porch, every moment here feels intentionally unhurried.

This home captures the essence of island living: graceful, relaxed, and filled with the timeless appeal of summer by the sea. Its well-appointed spaces, proximity to the beach, and connection to Fair Harbor’s cherished traditions make it an inviting place to return to year after year.


Show MoreLess


Own a Luxury Second Home?

Exchange your unused time and get access to this and other exclusive homes.

Get Started Here



Property Amenities

Pets Welcome Upon Approval | Not Handicap Accessible

Facilities
Office
Location features
Waterfront
Other
Air Conditioning
Coffee Maker
Crib
Washer & Dryer
Wireless Internet
Outdoor
Outdoor Grill
Outdoor Lounge



Property Details

Size

Private Residence with 2 Levels
4 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, 1360 square feet, 127 square meters

Bedrooms

King, Queen, Queen + Twin, and Queen + Twin
10 Guests maximum

Nearest airport

Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP)
1 hour 45 minutes by car and ferry

Property View

Lush dune, Treetop views, Glimpses of the bay

Additional Fees

$150 pet fee - per dog

Activities of Interest

  • Shopping
  • Watersports
  • Bike ride through Fire Island’s scenic communities
  • Beachcombing and shell collecting along the Atlantic coast
  • Sunset cocktails on the Fair Harbor dock
  • Paddleboarding or kayaking in the Great South Bay
  • Nature walk through the Sunken Forest
  • Visit the Fire Island Lighthouse and climb to the top
  • Enjoy fresh-baked goods from local kids’ stands
  • Attend seasonal community concerts or live music events
  • Day trip to Ocean Beach for boutique shopping
  • Stargazing from the beach or porch at night

Places of Interest

  • Sunken Forest – Explore a rare, boardwalk-accessible maritime forest
  • Sailors Haven – A scenic bayfront beach and nature preserve
  • Ocean Beach – Lively shops, restaurants, and galleries in a charming village setting
  • Kismet – Laid-back beach town with local dining and a marina
  • Fair Harbor Dock – Community hub for sunset viewing, music, and social gatherings